January 22, 2013
Europe’s commercial property investors opt for safe cities
German cities dominate the investment prospects for Europe’s commercial real estate sector as investors favour safe havens according to a new report – Emerging Trends in Real Estate Europe 2013. Munich tops the league table followed closely by Berlin in second place and Hamburg in fifth position, with investors taking comfort from each of the cities’ strong local micro-economic climate and resilient property market conditions. London, which is seen by many as Europe’s safest investment, is the largest riser in this year’s report taking third position.
Investors continue to be attracted by the size and liquidity of London’s real estate market, the stability of sterling as a currency and its ability to stand alone from the rest of the UK and Europe’s economic issues.
The report, published jointly by the Urban Land Institute (ULI) and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) ranks 27 cities across Europe, based on respondents’ expectations for market performance in 2013. Overall, the highest ranked cities are the larger Western European centres with international appeal and better economic prospects. In contrast, the worst performing cities were those in countries at the heart of the Eurozone crisis or struggling to cope with the consequences of the 2008 financial meltdown such as Athens, Lisbon, Dublin, Madrid and Barcelona.
Respondents to this year’s survey were more pessimistic on the outlook for cities’ property markets than they have been since 2004 but were the most optimistic about the future of their own businesses since 2008.
The report says that this is indicative of a wider trend, which sees a movement away from investment strategies centred on whole countries, cities or industry sectors and towards a focus on specific individual assets and opportunities.
‘Almost five years since the start of the financial crisis, real estate investors remain cautious about capital deployment and the availability of debt,’ said Joe Montgomery, chief executive of ULI Europe. ‘As a result investors are focusing on the harder to find opportunities in blue-chip cities such as Munich, Berlin, London and Paris, rather than turning to secondary locations in search of higher returns,’ he added.
Simon Hardwick, real estate partner at PwC Legal, said that the report shows that real estate investors are approaching opportunities with a new mindset, conscious that the environment in which they are operating is ‘the new normal’ and is set to stay the same for some time yet. ‘Investors face ongoing challenges but are cautiously optimistic about their prospects for the first time in many years,’ he added.
The report says that Munich’s strong and liquid market is appealing to investors looking for dependable locations that can withstand economic turbulence. ‘Munich has a mixture of global and mid-sized business occupiers and has expanding biotechnology, environmental sciences and media industries. The city’s prospects are underpinned by its demographics, with its population set to rise by 112,000 by 2025 and its existing inhabitants having a purchasing power unrivalled elsewhere in Germany,’ it says.
‘Low vacancy rates and constrained supply mean that investors are confident of rental growth in 2013, while a rapid increase in tourist numbers, especially from BRIC countries, provides a positive outlook for Munich’s retail market,’ it adds.
Berlin, which has been dubbed by many as Europe’s Silicon Alley, has a growing reputation as a technology hub with over 15,000 tech companies generating turnover of €19 billion per year. ‘The influx of skilled technology workers has had a boost on the city’s residential market where the inner-city luxury apartment market is growing, especially in districts such as Mitte which has seen significant rental increases. Berlin’s reputation as a cultural centre ensures it receives high visitor numbers benefitting both the apartment and hotel sectors,’ the report says.
London is one of the biggest risers in the 2013 survey, and this has been driven by its status as one of the world’s ultimate safe havens, according to the report. ‘The city is perceived as sitting apart from the problems in the wider UK and European economies and the size, strength and liquidity of its real estate market are attractive to many investors,’ it says.
‘There is some speculation that the recovery of values is complete but many see micro-market opportunities especially in the residential sector where super-prime homes in the very best postcodes and the under explored private rented sector are favoured,’ the report explains.
‘The City and Canary Wharf office markets are still attracting trophy hunters but the development of new offices for financial services businesses is out of favour as the sector sheds jobs. Opportunities exist to develop space for the city’s growing technology and creative industries,’ it adds.
While the other cities in the top five appeal to investors because of their inherent safety, the report states that Istanbul remains the most popular location for future development opportunity. ‘The city’s exciting real estate potential is driven by economic growth which rivals China and demographics where the average age in Turkey is only 29,’ it says.
‘Recent changes have eased restrictions on foreign ownership of Turkish real estate, as the government seeks to attract international capital and transform Istanbul into a regional financial centre. It is estimated by Turkey’s Association of Real Estate Investment Companies that these changes will boost investment in real estate by $5 billion a year,’ it adds.
Safe haven status is also boosting investor interest in Hamburg, Germany’s second largest city. ‘Hamburg benefits from a diverse mix of global occupiers and domestic small and medium sized businesses, with media remaining the city’s largest employment sector and the port acting as a crucial trade hub for goods from the Far East,’ says the report.
‘Investors are favouring offices, where prime yields of 4.75% are their lowest since 2002, as they are willing to pay the high price for the stability the market offers. However, with constrained office supply, appealing assets are becoming increasingly hard to source and some investors are switching to the city’s industrial sector,’ it adds.